July 31, 2006 'Respecting Lebanon's Sovereignty'
by Ran HaCohen
Nothing compares to Israel's open, independent, and pluralistic media in times of war. Saturday we had the pleasure of watching give an especially repulsive horror show on Israeli public television (Channel 1). Foxman was invited to the studio to comment on Kofi Annan's announcement that four UN observers had been apparently killed by Israel deliberately. From the for this subject to the style and content, the "interview" – in a prestigious foreign news weekly magazine –
Foxman cooperated enthusiastically. Annan had gained a lot of respect for his successful efforts to globally commemorate the Holocaust. In a dirty trick of demagoguery, Foxman explained these efforts away by saying the UN secretary-general (or "the secretary of state," as Foxman repeatedly misnamed him) liked only dead Jews, not living ones. Foxman also accused Annan of having "guilty feelings because of the Holocaust"; .
"Can anyone imagine," the infuriated demagogue rhetorically asked, "that the Jewish people would intentionally kill UN observers?!" Yes: Foxman actually used the term "the Jewish people" as the agent of the killing, following the , in which the entire "Jewish people" was blamed for whatever individual Jews had or had not done.
At this lunatic stage, the moderator tried, not once but twice, to add even more fuel to the fire by Alas, Foxman wasn't ready to go that far, and just reminded viewers that the UN had given Israel its "birth certificate," but had been in a "love-hate relationship" with the Jewish state ever since – again, because the Gentiles love us only when we are dead and buried, not when strong and "defending ourselves."
Prior to the interview, moderator Achimeir described Foxman as a friend of Annan's, and wondered whether the two would ever speak to each other again after the interview. I for my part would warmly advise Annan to keep away from a "friend" like Foxman, as long as the latter's mental condition has not been professionally diagnosed as non-contagious.
What the Observers Observed
The four UN observers killed by Israel last week had called the Israeli liaison officer urging him to stop bombing them. The Israeli army promised it would stop. It did stop, but only after the observers were killed. The following chronicle, copied from official reports of the UN Interim Force in Lebanon, is dedicated – among the dead – to the four unarmed UN observers, from China, Finland, Austria, and Canada, who were just carrying out their peaceful mission. Among the living, the chronicle is dedicated to all those who keep saying that Israel has respected Lebanon's sovereignty since 2000, when it ended its 22-year-long occupation; and to those who find the Hezbollah's breach of Israel's sovereignty an excuse good enough to devastate an entire prosperous land.
The UN Chronicle (Excerpts)
Interim report of the secretary-general on the UN Interim Force in Lebanon, April 30, 2001:
As before, there were . There were, in addition, I have been in touch with the parties concerned and other interested parties to urge respect for the Blue Line and to avert further escalation."
Report of the secretary-general for the period from July 18, 2000, to Jan. 18, 2001:
"Israeli violations of Lebanese air space, which had resumed after Hizbollah's attack on 7th October, ."
For the period from Jan. 23, 2001, to July 20, 2001:
"As reported in April, Israeli aircraft violated the line on an almost daily basis, penetrating deep into Lebanese airspace. These incursions, particularly those , were especially and caused great anxiety to the civilian population. The air violations are , despite repeated démarches to the Israeli authorities."
For the period from July 21, 2001, to Jan. 16, 2002:
"Israeli air violations of the Blue Line, however, continued on an almost daily basis, penetrating deep into Lebanese airspace. These incursions are not justified and cause great concerns to the civilian population, particularly low-altitude flights that break the sound barrier over populated areas. The air violations are ongoing, although démarches to the Israeli authorities […] have been made repeatedly by me, other senior United Nations officials and a number of interested Governments."
For the period from Jan. 17, 2002, to July 12, 2002:
"Unjustified Israeli air incursions into sovereign Lebanese airspace continued on an almost daily basis throughout most of the reporting period, often penetrating deep into Lebanon and frequently generating sonic booms. In the latter half of April, In January Hezbollah began with anti-aircraft fire. This activity has continued through the present. On a number of occasions […] shells crossed the Blue Line. Calls on Israel to cease the overflights […]"
For the period from July 13, 2002, to Jan. 14, 2003:
"There were sporadic Israeli violations of Lebanese airspace, with periodic lulls in such activity punctuated by abrupt increases over periods of several days. On two occasions in November, Israeli overflights exceeded any recorded number since Israel's withdrawal from southern Lebanon in May 2000. Many of these air violations penetrated deep into Lebanon, often generating sonic booms over populated areas. The pattern identified in my last report continued, whereby the aircraft would fly out to sea and enter Lebanese airspace north of the UNIFIL area of operation, thus avoiding direct observation and verification by UNIFIL."
For the period from Jan. 15, 2003, to July 23, 2003:
"The most significant sources of tension were the persistent Israeli violations of Lebanese airspace and instances of Hezbollah antiaircraft fire directed across the Blue Line towards Israeli villages. […] Israeli air incursions into Lebanon increased overall during the reporting period, though the numbers have declined since early July. UNIFIL recorded almost daily violations across the Blue Line in some weeks. As in the past, Israeli overflights penetrated deep into Lebanon, often generating sonic booms over populated areas."
For the period from July 24, 2003, to Jan. 19, 2004:
"The recurrent Israeli air incursions into Lebanon continued. The numbers abated at times but periods of little or no activity were invariably followed by an intensification of the flights. […] Hezbollah continued to react […]"
For the period from Jan. 21, 2004, to July 21, 2004:
"A cycle of disruptions and armed exchanges across the Blue Line commenced on 5 May. Israel carried out more than 20 air sorties over Lebanon, a number of which generated sonic booms. Hezbollah subsequently fired several antiaircraft rounds […]"
"Israeli air incursions were on the whole less frequent than in the previous period, although they were notable for their Israeli officials maintained that there would be overflights whenever Israel deemed them necessary. As in the past, Israeli aircraft often penetrated deep […] sonic booms over populated areas […] fly out to the sea […] avoiding direct observation […]"
For the period from July 21, 2004, to Jan. 20, 2005:
"Israeli air incursions into Lebanon continued throughout the reporting period. […] Israeli officials maintained the position that there would be overflights whenever they deemed them necessary. […] As in the past […]"
For the period from Jan. 21, 2005, to July 20, 2005:
"Violations of the Blue Line continued throughout the past six months, most often in the form of […] The Israeli Air Force continued their air incursion […] deep into Lebanon […] sonic booms […] whenever Israel deemed […]"
For the period from July 22, 2005, to Jan. 20, 2006:
"The Israeli Air Force violated Lebanese airspace on many occasions during the reporting period, disturbing the relative calm along the Blue Line. […] [I]n November, overflights by jets, helicopters and unmanned aerial vehicles or drones were numerous and […] There were […]."
What the Observers Won't Observe Anymore
The more the UN reports repeat themselves, the less attention the media pays them. And just as Israelis wonder about the purpose of Hezbollah's missile arsenal, so could Lebanon, and so should we all,
And as for the killing of the observers, Cluster munitions? Other crimes? We might never know.